This is a list of instances in which eyelids can be seen on the eyes of Sprout puppet characters who don't normally have them, or they've been extended for those that do. This is usually done to create the appearance of sleep, when the simpler method of turning the character's eyes from the camera won't work for the scene.
| Image | Character | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Star | The penultimate segment of The Good Night Show (after Ready for Bed); At the end of The Good Night Show and in Sprout's Snooze-a-Thon and "La La Lullaby" while sleeping. | |
| Chica | Sprout's Snooze-a-Thon; Great Sprout Tuck-In PSA; "La La Lullaby"; The Chica Show "Tweet Dreams Chica"; in a segment with Carly; in a segment with Willie and Christina Geist; in two promotional shots. | |
 |
Noodle McNoodle | Sprout's Snooze-a-Thon; "La La Lullaby" |
 |
Banjo | Sprout's Snooze-a-Thon; Great Sprout Tuck-In PSA while sleeping outside. |
